(standing is an Irishman)
Puck Magazine, June 1889
A great many people today can look at this map...
...and conclude, 'This can only spell good things for America.'
Why?
'Anglo-America absorbed millions of alien immigrants in the 19th century, then went on to become the biggest superpower in world history!'
As it happens, both these statements are true. It is also true that after metal helmets replaced leather ones, the number of soldiers' head injuries increased. So did America become a huge superpower
because, or
in spite of, these aliens? Or a little of both?
And if these waves of 19th c. foreigners did make her stronger, can the same be said of the millions streaming in yearly now?
The question is by no means flip. Many of the arguments used by immigration restrictionists in 2012 are identical to those used a hundred years ago. It's a case of Chicken Little, says our open-border contingent--'Your predecessors said the sky would fall; it didn't, and this time it won't either.'
Who's right?
Why, just look at this mosaic:
A propositional nation,
n'est-ce pas?